Monday, May 25, 2009

Not Just an Economic Crisis

And so again after a visit to Renu's blog, I'm compelled to convert a comment into a post, because one thought led to another which led to a third ..... so on and so forth, till its just too long in the comment form.

Straight off, let me say that I struggled mightily with economics and finance in my formal education and still do not fully understand the intricacies of both. But what I do understand very clearly is this: you violate His laws, you will pay a price someday. As you sow, so shall you reap, or to borrow my sister's favourite acronym, JKVB - Jaisi Karni Vaise Bharni (and now look at the amazing coincidence that as I was going through some of my regular blogs, I came across Goofy Mumma's latest!)

In many places, I recall the current economic crisis being described as the failure of the capitalist philosophy. I disagree.

I see this crisis as the failure of regulatory authorities who should've ensured organizations didn't overstretch their limits. I see this crisis as a failure of organizations themselves in that they were over-ambitious. Most importantly, I see this economic crisis as an after-effect, the result of a much more deeper cause: a moral, ethical & spiritual failure.

Very simply, people got greedy.

Right from childhood, we're taught that greed is bad. In fact, Christianity considers it as one of seven deadly sins. Deadly sin. I find it really amazing that people get so immersed in their careers and money-making that they forget these basic truths along the way. Many will scoff at anything to do with religion & spirituality; they outright dismiss simple values as 'touchy-feely crap' and see them as having no connection to the "business world".

And yet, when this crisis first erupted, and companies - supposedly well-established industry giants - started collapsing one after the other, the first thing people ran towards was God. Churches, in New York City especially, reported record attendance as desperate souls from the corporate world turned to Him for some way out of the mess they'd gotten themselves into.

I repeat: you violate His laws, you will pay a price someday. You can't ..... restrict God to a slot in your life. You can't say, ok God, I'll come see you in so&so place of worship, I'll give some money to xyz charity and that's it, be happy with that, what I do in my job is my business, not Yours.

Many people (including some members of my own family), believe that their "security" and their "status" lies in the size of their bank balance. Everything else comes in second to the all-important goal of money. Instead of work being a part of life, it becomes their whole life, to the exclusion of God, their own health and personal relationships. So when you make that sort of uncontrolled greed your way of life ....... how do you expect to walk away unscathed? And for a crisis of this magnitude to have occurred, its not just a few people here and there who went astray, but entire generations, entire societies that are to blame.

Anything taken to an extreme is bad; so the fault does not lie in capitalism per se, but in the unchecked, unbridled capitalism and materialism. I still believe in the capitalist philosophy, so long as we operate within a moral and ethical framework at the individual and the larger organizational and societal levels.

The values of hard work, honesty, saving and spending within your means are extolled by most faiths, and they are meant to guide us in all aspects of life. They are NOT irrelevant or outdated in present times however "modern" we consider ourselves, and whatever our accomplishments, none of us is above them. Provided we adhere to these guidelines, we have every right to enjoy the fruits of our efforts.

9 comments:

  1. You've actually put forward all the viewpoints tht I'm at a loss for words to comment.
    "I see this economic crisis as an after-effect, the result of a much more deeper cause: a moral, ethical & spiritual failure."
    "Anything taken to an extreme is bad; so the fault does not lie in capitalism per se, but in the unchecked, unbridled capitalism and materialism."
    Especially in these 2 sentences.

    I myself firmly believe tht whtever good we do, may or may not come back to us but if we think or act negetively there is a double price to pay & tht too in this lifetime itself.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Very true Shalom - what you said was immensely correct. We dis regarded some very basic laws and thus the heavy prce... but end of day- hope floats

    ReplyDelete
  3. Shalom, I wish more could think like you but that's not the case. Basic laws of every faith is the same but still it is twisted for individual gains.

    Even though I am a believer of 'Karma', I have seen some people just getting away even after wrong doings. I question it sometimes and retrospect then that feeling passes as you see better things around.

    One thing I am sure of is that if I knowingly hurt someone then I can't sleep at night. No..I am no saint and I do go harsh on people too but you know hurting a good soul now that is just not right.

    Did I digress? :D

    ReplyDelete
  4. I liked certain lines like "You violate his laws, you pay the price". Its the universal truth and sometimes we get so immersed in our career to do justice to values.

    About the economic scenario,i would consider it as the after-effect of the capitalist mind. as you said, greediness went to such great levels so that people who were supposed to be the guardians of the economy turned a blind eye to the whirlpool destruction which has created havoc across the world !

    ReplyDelete
  5. you violate His laws, you will pay a price someday. As you sow, so shall you reap, ---I firmly believe in this.
    you are right that fault doesnt lie with capitalism but with people.
    If we do business ethically..we generate wealth and employment both....here what happened that big compnies were growing not because their products were selling but because of their big debts....kehte hain...jitnee chadar ho utne hi pair failaane chahiye...here everybody bought, spent and consumed more than he could affors and the result is there for everyone to see.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Shalom, That was a fantastic post! And I agree with everything you've said!Yes, it is NOT a failure of the capitalist philosophy.. As you say 'the failure of regulatory authorities who should've ensured organizations didn't overstretch their limits'.
    and
    'Anything taken to an extreme is bad; so the fault does not lie in capitalism per se, but in the unchecked, unbridled capitalism and materialism'

    Yes, things would be so much easier if people did realise what you say here 'Provided we adhere to these guidelines, we have every right to enjoy the fruits of our efforts.'

    You've said it all so beautifully!

    ReplyDelete
  7. Reflections - sadly most people don't understand that there are consequences for their actions.


    Amrita - yup, hope always floats. If we mend our ways, things will definitely improve.


    Solilo - not exactly a digression :D Sometimes it seems as if people are getting away with bad behaviour....in the short term. My belief in karma comes from live experiences within my family itself....it may take decades sometimes, but that punishment for deliberate wrongdoing does come sometime or the other.


    Prashant - its very easy for ppl to get tempted by greed, but hopefully current & future generations should learn from these mistakes, so we never again get sucked into such a whirlpool, as you rightly described it.


    Renu - I really liked that saying! The problem is that everyone wants the "good life" & they want it right now, regardless of whether they can afford it.


    Smitha - thanks :) Certainly, we should enjoy our lives, that's one reason we work so hard, but there's a limit to how much you should work, how much you should enjoy. What we're seeing now is what happens when you cross those limits.

    ReplyDelete
  8. I agree completely. And a correction was inevitable. Only wish it was fair and affected only the perpetrators...

    ReplyDelete
  9. Lan - yes, I definitely feel for the innocent employees of the companies that crashed.

    ReplyDelete